Understand the choices in the Alberta separation debate, how provincial autonomy works, and why Same As Quebec advocates negotiating a stronger Alberta within Canada.
Alberta separatism is the position that Alberta should leave Canada and become an independent country. Alberta separation and Alberta independence are commonly used to describe that goal. Greater provincial autonomy is a different goal: more provincial choice while remaining part of Canada.
Same As Quebec is a pro-Canada movement advocating a stronger Alberta within Canada. Its proposal is to negotiate provincial arrangements that better reflect Alberta's priorities. The movement does not advocate Alberta independence or taking anything away from Quebec.
Alberta autonomy means exercising or negotiating provincial authority within Canada's constitutional framework. Alberta independence means leaving Canada to become a separate state. Same As Quebec focuses on the first path, with proposals evaluated for their legal and economic consequences before implementation.
No. A referendum would not, by itself, make Alberta an independent country. The federal Clarity Act recognizes that lawful provincial secession requires a constitutional amendment and negotiations involving at least the federal government and all provincial governments. It sets conditions concerning a clear question and a clear majority before the federal government can negotiate secession; it does not prescribe a fixed numerical majority threshold.
Same As Quebec supports a referendum as a way to seek a democratic mandate for negotiating provincial arrangements within Canada. The question would need to make that purpose clear. A mandate to negotiate greater autonomy should not be presented as a vote for Alberta independence, and it would not automatically require Ottawa to accept the proposals.
Quebec provides examples of different provincial arrangements within Canada, including the Canada–Quebec immigration accord and the Quebec Pension Plan. Same As Quebec asks whether Alberta can negotiate comparable opportunities where constitutionally possible. The proposal is to examine those arrangements on their merits, rather than assume Alberta should copy every Quebec policy.
The five areas are immigration, pensions, policing, equalization and resources, and provincial resource jurisdiction. The proposals seek a comparable opportunity for provincial choice. They are starting points for discussion, with independent legal, fiscal and actuarial review needed before implementation.
No. Provincial pension arrangements and independence are separate questions. Quebec operates its own pension plan while remaining part of Canada, and the Canada Pension Plan covers Canada outside Quebec. Same As Quebec calls for an independently analyzed, informed choice for Albertans; the existence of the Quebec plan does not establish what a proposed Alberta plan would cost or deliver.
Alberta's provincial government does not make a direct equalization payment to Quebec. Equalization is financed from federal general revenues, largely federal taxes paid across Canada. Provincial governments do not contribute to the program. Same As Quebec proposes reviewing resource treatment and fiscal-capacity measures, with the debate grounded in how the formula actually works.
Savings should not be assumed. The costs and benefits depend on each proposal, including administration, transition expenses, service delivery and any negotiated financial arrangements. Same As Quebec calls for proposals to be tested on the facts and economics before implementation, including independent actuarial analysis for pension choices.
Start with the primary sources linked on this site: the Canada–Quebec Accord, federal pension information, RCMP publications, Finance Canada transfer information and the Constitution. These sources support factual comparisons. They do not, by themselves, endorse the movement's policy proposals.
Use the supporter form to share your name, email, community and area of interest. The founding team is looking for people from business, agriculture, energy, education, public policy and local communities who want to help test the ideas, strengthen the research or organize locally.
Updated September 8, 2026. Policy proposals are the movement's positions; primary-source links are provided for the factual comparisons.